Self-report study is a measure of crime involving the distribution of a detailed questionnaire to a sample of people, asking them whether they have committed a crime in a particular period of time. Self-report study has been useful to determine the social characteristics of offenders. Self report studies involve confidential questionnaires that invite the respondents to record voluntarily whether or not they have committed any of the listed offences. Self-report studies are commonly used in psychological studies because valuable and diagnostic information about a person is revealed to a researcher based on a person’s report on himself or herself. Self-report study measures may reflect a common underlying dimension of negative affectivity, thereby leading to spurious results.
how serious a threat to self-report studies of psychological distress?
Serious questions have been raised about the common practice of relying on self-report study measures to assess the relation between subjective role experiences on the one hand and both mental and physical health symptoms on the other. - Brennan RT, Barnett RC.
Juvenile Crime and
Sanctions in the Netherlands - Karin Wittebrood.
Trends in juvenile crime in the Netherlands are described using police statistics and self-report studies. A sharp rise in juvenile crime is suggested by the police statistics, while the self-report studies reveal a more stable picture. Attention has been paid to explanations of this discrepancy.
Herman and Julia Schwendinger introduce their book, Adolescent Subcultures and Delinquency as follows:
There is a theoretical crisis in criminology. It began when self-report studies questionnaire uncovered an unexpected amount of middle-class delinquency. These studies indicated that delinquency cuts across class lines to a greater degree than police statistics suggest.
The self-report studies therefore contradicted theories explaining delinquency on the basis of lower-class conditions. They also lent credence to Tittle and Villemez's (1977) extraordinary claim that social class relationships have nothing to do with criminal behavior. The debate over the self-report studies has reached an intensity unprecedented in theoretical criminology. (1985, p.xi).
Sex Differences in Self-Report Delinquency -
RACHELLE J. CANTER.
ABSTRACT: This study describes the distribution, nature, pattern, and magnitude of sex differences in self-report delinquency. A national probability sample of 1725 youths, ages 11-17, was interviewed using a comprehensive measure of self-report delinquency including serious and violent crimes.
Disparities in preventive procedures: comparisons of self-report and Medicare claims data. Kevin Fiscella, Kathleen Holt, Sean Meldrum, Peter Franks.
Abstract: Background: Racial and ethnic disparities are assessed using either self-report or claims data. We compared these two data sources and examined contributors to discrepancies in estimates of disparities. Results: With the exception of PSA testing, racial/ethnic disparities in preventive procedures are generally larger when using Medicare claims than when using patients' self-report.
Analyses that minorities were more likely to self-report preventive procedures in the absence of claims. Rates of claims in the absence of self-report were low. Minorities were more likely to have PSA test claims in the absence of self-reports, but were less likely to have influenza vaccination claims in the absence of self-reports.
CRIME AND PERSONALITY REVISITED - Effects of MMPI Response Sets in Self-Report Studies. SPENCER A. RA THUS, LARRY J. SIEGEL. Abstract: The present study explored the effects of MMPI response sets on relatonships between crime and personality in self-report studies. The MMPI-168 and a 21-item delinquent behavior questionnaire were administered to 1680 high school students.
Vandalism and self-report studies - a review of
the literature - M Stace. Victoria university of Wellington, institute of criminology, New Zealand this paper
reviews the literature dealing with both vandalism and self-report studies in New
Zealand. Abstract: the first part of the paper reviews literature since 1954 on vandalism in New
Zealand; the second part reviews the literature on self-report studies. Various methods
used to check response validity indicate that self-reports are generally valid.
Self-report studies have often been used on minors, but future efforts could be directed
toward white-collar crime.
TRENDS AND PATTERNS OF SELF-REPORTED JUVENILE DELINQUENCY IN FINLAND - Janne Kivivuori. The report includes chapters by five authors. All contributions are based on self-report surveys of juvenile delinquency. Chapters 24 are based on the fourth sweep (2001) of the Finnish Self-Report Delinquency Study (FSRD). The previous sweeps were carried out in 1995, 1996 and 1998. The FSRD indicator system targets ninth-grade (1516-year-old) students in Finnish-language schools. Chapters 5 and 6 utilize local self-report studies conducted in the cities of Helsinki and Turku.
Male and female differences in self-report cheating - James A Athanasou, Olabisi Olasehinde. Cheating is an important area for educational research, not only because it reduces the consequential validity of assessment results, but also because it is anathema to widely held public principles of equity and truthfulness. The purpose of this paper is to review the extent of academic cheating and to describe any gender differences in self-report studies.
An Exploration of the External Validity of Self-Report amongst Arrestees - David Patton. Abstract: Self-report validation surveys in the USA focussing on arrestees self-reports unequivocally demonstrate that they do not validly report their recent drug consumption despite being a highly drug involved group. Data used from the NEW -ADAM programme (1998) is used to explore the extern al validity of arrestees self-report studies to drug consumption in the 3 days prior to interview.
A Review of Sex Differences in Sexual Jealousy, Including Self-Report Data, Psychophysiological Responses, Interpersonal Violence, and Morbid Jealousy. - Christine R. Harris, Center for Brain Cognition, University of California, San Diego. Abstract: The specific innate modular theory of jealousy hypothesizes that natural selection shaped sexual jealousy as a mechanism to prevent cuckoldry, and emotional jealousy as a mechanism to prevent resource loss. Therefore, men should be primarily jealous over a mate's sexual infidelity and women over a mate's emotional infidelity. Five lines of evidence have been offered as support: self-report study responses, psychophysiological data, domestic violence, and morbid jealousy cases.
Enhancing the Validity of Self-Reported Alcohol and Marijuana Consumption Using a Bogus Pipeline Procedure: A Meta-Analytic Review - Herman Aguinis, Charles A. Pierce, Brian M. Quigley. To test whether the use of self-report measures within the bogus pipeline paradigm yields more valid responses than the use of self-report measures alone for assessing alcohol and marijuana consumption. Weighted mean effect sizes (ds) of 0.01 and -0.12 were obtained for studies using alcohol and marijuana self-reports, respectively. Explanations for why a BPL procedure does not improve the validity of self-reported alcohol and marijuana consumption are provided. In addition, alternative methods that may enhance the validity of alcohol and marijuana self-reports are discussed.
Discrepancies Between Self-Reported and Official Measures of Delinquency - Leroy C. Gould.